
For as good as both the Cubs and White Sox were in 2008, they're almost equally as bad in 2009. That being said I'm taking a cue from the Chicago Tribune's
Phil Rogers and submitting my Chicago All-City team as the teams get set for the first of a three-game set at Wrigley Field beginning tonight.
Catcher - The Sox'
A.J. Pierzynski is as durable as they come, but he has never been known for his offensive prowess. On the North Side,
Geovany Soto is the reigning National League Rookie of the Year and All-Star starter behind the dish. Whatever the reason, Soto has not lived up to that billing in 2009. He is struggling mightily at the plate with just three homers and 16 RBI through 50 games. Batting average (.223) and slugging percentage (.318) are also way down.
My vote goes to A.J. The veteran's power numbers aren't great (6 and 15), but that's never been his game. He's hitting for average (.303) and producing wherever manager
Ozzie Guillen slides him into the lineup.
First Base - Both
Paul Konerko and
Derrek Lee have been good, but not great in 2009. Konerko is having a much better season than he did a year ago when he was plagued by injuries. He's got 8 home runs and 41 RBI. He's batting .294 with a .471 slugging percentage. He did miss a few games with a thumb injury last week, but came back strong in two wins over the Brewers. Lee struggled through April and much of May, but has quietly recovered. He's got 7 homers and 27 RBI, but is a far cry from where he was in 2005 when he finished third in the NL MVP voting.
My pick is PK over D-Lee.
Second Base - Do we have to pick one? The Cubs have about four candidates to choose from while the Southsiders have a couple of their own. For the sake of this argument, I am going to make the finalists
Chris Getz for the White Sox (over
Jayson Nix)
and
Mike Fontenot (over
Aaron Miles and two or three Iowa Cubs to be named later). Getz, in his first full season, has played some very solid defense and a few nice moments at the plate. Fontenot's average is in the gutter (.236), but he does have 6 homers and 26 RBI for the Cubs. He's also been asked to fill in at third base for the ailing
Aramis Ramirez, which he's done with mixed results.
I vote for Fontenot, but I believe that Nix would be the best if he got more regular playing time.
Shortstop - A second slow start for
Alexei Ramirez means that the Cubs'
Ryan Theriot gets the vote. There is no doubt that Ramirez is a better defender, but Theriot has proved to be no slouch. Theriot already has a career-high six home runs and is on-pace to set a new high in RBI also. His average is down from 2008, but slugging and OPS are both up. Ramirez has raised his average from .203 on May 1st to .252 today. He's also walked 17 times (18 in all of 2008) and collected 10 stolen bases (13 last year). I've got an idea. How about we slot Ramirez at his 2008 position (2B) to avoid picking though the garbage we've seen from both sides this season?
Third Base -
Josh Fields appears lost at the plate and looks nothing like the guy who belted 27 homers when
Joe Crede went down in 2007. Since being called up,
Gordon Beckham has not performed at the plate either. Fontenot already won at second base by default and any of the Iowa Cubs to be named later don't fit here either. I'm going to have to piggy-back Rogers and
select ailing Cubs' 3B Aramis Ramirez. Ramirez has played in just 18 games, but in that time he has more homers (4) than Fields (3) has in 55. Unfortunately for the Cubs, Ramirez is struggling to get back on the field and could miss another 3-4 weeks.
Left field - The nominees here are
Alfonso Soriano and
Scott Podsednik. Pods, a 2005 cult-hero, didn't even join the big league club until May 1st, but he's had a positive impact at the top of the lineup since. He slid over to LF when
Carlos Quentin went to the disabled list and has done a fine job getting on base at the top of the lineup. He's batting .311 with an OBP of .360. He's also stolen 8 bases and scored 18 runs. For the Cubs, Soriano has 14 homers, but just 27 RBI. His average is terrible at .229 and he has already struck out 66 times.
Soriano, I guess.
Center field - The
Brian Anderson - Dewayne Wise - Brent Lillibridge trio hasn't produced very good numbers, so this pick is pretty simple: the Cubs'
Kosuke Fukudome. He looked great in April, but has steadily declined in production each month of the season. Just like second base, I'd rather slide Podsednik over to center and have Soriano in left than pick from the existing crop of candidates.
Right field -
Milton Bradley is in the argument for the worst free agent signing this past winter, while
Jermaine Dye has been as steady as ever patrolling right field for the Sox. Dye has seen a dip in his batting average, but he's got 15 homers and 39 RBI. He's also playing great defense for a guy whose legs have seen better days.
Dye gets the vote and could end up being the Sox' lone representative at the All-Star Game in St. Louis (though I hope Mark Buehrle and Matt Thornton get invited as well).
Bat off the bench - This could be the easiest no-brainer on the board:
Jim Thome. He gets on base (.403), he hits home runs (12) and he drives in runs (39). Thome continues to cement his status as a Hall of Famer.
Reliever - Matt Thornton might be the best left-handed relief pitcher in the game. He throws 97-99 MPH with ease and he's been in the right spot to collect four wins in relief so far. I REALLY hope that AL manager
Joe Maddon recognizes his importance and brings him along to St. Louis in July.
Closer - At 14 of 16 saves converted,
Bobby Jenks has been more consistent than his counterpart,
Kevin Gregg on the the North Side. Jenks might not be as dominant as he once was in the second-half of 2005 and 2006, but he's still getting it done.
Starter - To me, it comes down to one guy on each side of town. A couple of lefties have been the most consistent pitchers in Chicago -
Ted Lilly for the Cubs and
Mark Buehrle for the White Sox. Lilly is 7-4 with a 2.94 ERA, while Buehrle is 6-4 with a 3.23 ERA, though he has had a couple of tough no decisions that could easily take him to 8 wins. He also hit his first career homer in Milwaukee over the weekend, which is nice.
I'm going to choose Lilly. Hopefully if the Cubs make it to the playoffs in 2009,
Lou Piniella won't be dumb enough to keep Lilly on the shelf through the first three games like he did last season.
Sox - 5 (Pierzynski, Konerko, Dye, Thornton and Jenks)
Cubs - 6 (Fontenot, Theriot, Ar. Ramirez, Soriano, Fukudome, Lilly)